Analyzing Pepperdine’s Extreme Decline in Alumni Contributions in 2023
[Editor’s Note: for more updated coverage on this topic, please see this Beacon article here.]
As a private university, Pepperdine’s revenue depends heavily on alumni contributions to maintain financial stability, support student services, expand scholarship opportunities, and keep tuition affordable. Because of these benefits, it is essential for Pepperdine University to maximize alumni contributions to remain a competitive university. Based on Pepperdine’s form 990s from 2021-2023, Pepperdine experienced fairly high alumni donations in 2021 and 2022, with the University bringing in around $67 million and $72 million, respectively. However, that number steeply dropped in 2023, with the University only raising $44 million in alumni contributions, a shocking drop of $28 million in contributions, and a stark 40% decline from the prior fiscal year.
For reference, compared to the other California-based nonprofit private Universities in Pepperdine’s West Coast Conference (Loyola Marymount University, University of San Diego, University of San Francisco, and University of the Pacific), only the University of San Francisco experienced a contribution decline in 2023, although it was a fairly small decline at 9% in comparison to Pepperdine’s 40%. Loyola Marymount, the University of San Diego, and the University of the Pacific all increased their alumni contributions from 2022-2023, with the University of San Diego and Loyola Marymount nearly surpassing Pepperdine in 2023 revenue in the process despite each school’s lower tuition. Of these schools, Pepperdine had the single lowest alumni contributions for 2023, despite having the second-largest alumni network of the five schools. In 2023, Pepperdine’s average donation per alumni was $441, far less than Loyola Marymount’s per alumni donation of $699, the University of San Diego’s per alumni donation of $952.86, and the University of the Pacific’s per alumni donation of $1,473.74.
Interestingly, Pepperdine had the highest total alumni contributions of the five schools in 2021 and 2022, yet Pepperdine’s nearly 40% drop in 2023 contributions moved the University from the single-highest alumni contributions of the five schools to the single lowest, falling even below the University of the Pacific despite Pepperdine having over 100,000 alumni to Pacific’s 34,000. In the same three-year time frame, none of these other Universities have experienced a single-year contribution decline of more than 9.5%, a far cry from Pepperdine’s nearly 40% decline in 2023. This shocking decline in 2023, unique to Pepperdine among its peers, raises the question: why aren’t Pepperdine alumni donating to their alma mater?
From a purely financial standpoint, one primary reason alumni may not be donating is simple: they may still be paying off their student loans. Of the alumni of the five aforementioned schools, Pepperdine alumni experience the highest monthly median loan payment. While Pepperdine alumni do, on average, earn slightly higher salaries relative to these other schools, these higher salaries may not be enough to compensate for predatory lending, excessive loan amounts, and compounding interest rates. While some of this is out of Pepperdine’s hands, the university has also done little to curb its excessive tuition costs, contributing to alumni experiencing the highest loans of similar universities in the region, making them far less likely to donate than alumni of other schools with smaller loan payments.
Alternatively, another explanation for this decline is simply that 2022 alumni donations were an outlier, and 2023 alumni donations are more in line with the standard numbers produced by Pepperdine. Pepperdine led these five schools in alumni contributions in both 2021 and 2022, so even if Pepperdine’s 2023 donations are more of a market correction, it still points towards instability in Pepperdine’s donation model, as a 40% annual drop in contributions is extremely volatile no matter how the numbers are framed.
This decline in alumni contributions may also stem from Pepperdine’s decline in national rankings, as the university has fallen from 48th in the US News Rankings to 80th within the last five years. This may negatively impact alumni’s perception of Pepperdine’s value, as they feel that the university has not taken ample steps to maintain the value of the degree that they worked and paid for. In this sense, many alumni may feel let down by the university, as they may have chosen Pepperdine based on a certain level of degree prestige that is arguably no longer present based on the school’s sharp drop in rankings within the last few years. Ironically, the lack of alumni donations may be more of a contributor to the rankings decline than a source, as 3% of US News’ ranking system is based on alumni contribution percentages, which is believed to reflect alumni satisfaction, and Pepperdine’s 2023 decline in alumni contributions is correlated with its decline in national rankings. Therefore, these negative effects could potentially be feeding into each other, creating a harmful cycle where both continue to decline simultaneously.
Another potential explanation for declining alumni contributions lies in the University administration’s increasingly overt politicization. On March 4, 2024, Pepperdine University’s Instagram page posted photographs of former Vice President Mike Pence visiting the School of Public Policy. The post was met with hundreds of comments critical of the University’s invitation of Pence, with many alumni explicitly stating that these decisions will affect their donations, with one alumni commenting that that “as an alum, I’ll be sending WavesOnCall to voicemail until I see steps back in the right direction,” with another commenting “continually embarrassed to have my name attached to this school!! No wonder alumni engagement is so low.” The top comment for the post, with over 230 likes, is “*me, disassociating more and more from my alma mater.”
While this, of course, does not provide concrete data that Pepperdine’s increased politicization is directly contributing to the drop in alumni donations, the multitudes of alumni comments expressing their frustration with the University’s direction is certainly concerning amidst declining contributions. Even if Pepperdine’s political leaning attracts higher donations from alumni on that side of the political spectrum, on the aggregate, it may be alienating too many alumni to make the move financially sustainable. While many may appreciate Pepperdine’s increased association with the political right, there may be a middle ground, open-dialogue approach for Pepperdine to maintain its values without alienating potential alumni contributors who feel frustrated with the University’s current direction.
Going forward, while Pepperdine’s 2023 alumni contribution decline was certainly steep, it is only a decline over one year. While Pepperdine’s 2024 alumni contributions are not yet publicly available at the time of this publication, I encourage the Pepperdine community to examine the 2024 form 990 data when it is publicly released, as it may further point to the severity and cause of Pepperdine’s alumni contribution problem. If these alumni contributions continue to decline, students will more than likely end up bearing the cost through increased tuition to make up for the university’s lost revenue. This could result in a kind of domino effect, where Pepperdine’s increased tuition further increases student loans, which decreases alumni’s means to contribute, leading to another drop in national rankings and degree prestige. If these trends continue, Pepperdine will urgently need to reevaluate its priorities and alumni engagement strategies to remain both a financially and reputationally competitive university.
magnificent writing!
Very interesting article. It is unfortunate that alumni are so politicized themselves that they cannot appreciate that speakers do not dictate the “politics” of an institution and it seems to me to be pretty shallow to disassociate oneself from your alma mater because you don’t like a particular speaker. Diversity of thought is extremely important in the world of ideas and it might make sense for some to actually listen to what a speaker says rather than brand them with a label. Your article is excellent!
Respectably, Claudia, as an alumnus, I would be more forgiving if there were a greater diversity in ideas and speakers, as opposed to those consistently espousing near identical beliefs. Pepperdine has always been a conservative bastion, so Mike Pence and Jordan Peterson do not signal “diversity of thought” to me in this context.
I hope Pepperdine will always be more conservative and more right wing in its leaning. As an alumnus I went there because of this and the high ranking of the school was appreciated, ranking the the 48 percent was excellent, and dropping to the 80’s is of concern.