Pepperdine’s Great Books Department and School of Public Policy (SPP) hosted Dr. Joseph Loconte, a New York Times bestselling author, educator, and filmmaker, on Tuesday, October 13, to discuss his recent book, “The War for Middle-earth: J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis Confront the Gathering Storm, 1933–1945.”
Dr. Loconte’s lecture, “War, Friendship, and Imagination,” examined how two of the twentieth century’s most beloved and celebrated authors used their literary talents to “hold the line” against unprecedented assaults on the moral norms of Western civilization.
Amid the political upheaval, ideological extremism, and moral disillusionment of their time, Tolkien and Lewis wielded the sword of imagination to fight for truth, goodness, and beauty.
While we are not living in the shadow of one world war while bracing ourselves for the horrors of another (and thank goodness we are not), our contemporary culture is not so different from Tolkien’s and Lewis’s as we might wish. We, too, live in an age marked by polarization, political extremism, and a growing disenchantment with the institutions and ideals that have long sustained our common life.
“Modernism rejects the idea that there is a moral or spiritual purpose to our mortal lives,” Dr. Loconte explained. In response to this, Tolkien and Lewis sought to illuminate the profound moral and spiritual significance inherent in human existence. Their stories teach us that the proper response to a disillusioned world is to recover and preserve our moral imaginations, not surrender them. The power of friendship, storytelling, and beauty is indispensable to any society engulfed in warfare–whether political, cultural, or physical.
As Dr. Loconte aptly noted, “War is the spark that lights the flame of imagination.” Though war brings humanity’s lust for power and propensity for radical evil into clearer focus, it cannot tell us how we ought to confront these realities of human life.
The circumstances of their age certainly animated Tolkien’s and Lewis’s writings. “Both authors convey the idea of a cosmic struggle between the forces of life and the forces of darkness,” Dr. Loconte observed. The World Wars, amidst their devastation, helped inspire the epic adventures of Frodo and Bilbo Baggins and the allegorical world of Narnia. The truths embedded in these great books speak to the reality of our own lives. They give the world a vision of life as it was meant to be. Lewis and Tolkien imagined worlds of enduring, extraordinary beauty where the force of evil is rivaled and ultimately defeated by sacrifice, friendship, courage, and goodness.
The deep and tragic irony of our modern age is that we are too busy warring with one another to actually live out the vision of life that we fight for. But hope is not lost. The lives of Lewis and Tolkien reveal that timeless truth, beauty, and goodness will always overpower the darkness. Perhaps this is precisely why we need the stories of Lewis and Tolkien now more than ever before.
Recognizing such truth and beauty may require us to see beyond our current circumstances. There are certain assumptions that we should try our hardest to unlearn. During Dr. Loconte’s lecture, he discussed Lewis’s 1933 work, The Pilgrim’s Regress, a story about a pilgrim embarking on a journey in pursuit of truth and beauty. The protagonist has to confront and unlearn many of the assumptions of his era before he is able to recognize the very things he was longing for. I think we are much like him. Our world is not lacking in beauty, friendship, or goodness; we are just not disposed to see it.
One SPP student shared her reflections on the conversation. “We must unlearn plenty of cultural and social norms to gain the liberty to see properly,” she said. “This makes me think about our society today. What must we unlearn now in our politically polarized, divided, and progressive, individualistic nation? And what does that help us to see? We might just rediscover the simple beauty of the Shire and learn how to carry the very real burden of our own ‘rings’ through the power of friendship and community.”
We are all called to stand against the evils of our age. Perhaps for some of us that will look like ordinary acts of courage, friendship, sacrifice, and love. For others, it might look like creating beauty through storytelling, art, and writing. The animosity of our time requires that we all, in our own small ways, “hold the line” by refusing to sacrifice our moral imaginations on the altar of political triumph; we must all wield our own sword of imagination in the fight to preserve truth and goodness.
In Dr. Joseph Loconte’s words, “Friends, there is light and beauty beyond the walls of this world. May each of us find the courage, and the grace, and the faith to see it.”