When people hear the word “thrift” in 2024, most associate the term with stores like The Salvation Army or Goodwill. The modern idea of thrift seems to revolve around an economic exchange– money for secondhand goods, a transactional agreement.
There has been a cultural shift and posture toward thrifting in the US, as many influencers on TikTok, YouTube, and other social media platforms regularly post their thrift store finds or tips on effectively thrifting. For instance, Alexa Sunshine83 on YouTube dedicates her channel to thrifting, emphasizing its sustainability and the enjoyment of the thrifting process. This influencer is among many individuals on Youtube who dedicate hours to thrifting, filming, editing videos, and providing content for their followers to watch. For us in 2025, thrifting has become a hobby, a pastime, and a skill; meanwhile, its roots are distinct yet familiar.
In 1919, the US Treasury Department (hereafter, US T.D.) published a book called Ten Lessons in Thrift, where the word thrift was defined as “a thriving condition; prosperity, success, good fortune” and “care and prudence in the management of one’s affairs.” It is clear here that thrift was seen as more than what we understand the term to mean today. The definition provided by the Treasury Department provocatively suggests a philosophically weighted term, as it uses non-strict-economic terms. In other words, the term proposed then was beyond pragmatism and dollar bills.
In 1919, thrift was much more than a hobby. It was a value, an ethic, a way of life. Interestingly, an entity of the federal government, the US T.D., was pushing thrift propaganda as a way to encourage its citizens to be prudent with their money.
Historically, according to the US T.D., to be a thrifty person was “essential”. As said in the Thrift and Savings Movement Brochure, “There was reclaimed in 1918 almost two billion dollars worth of waste material” and “there are a million and a quarter dependent people in America being fed and cared for out of the incomes of others”. There was an economic crisis, the US T.D. acknowledged it, and they capitalized on the economic crisis as evidence of the need for thrift to be an implanted ideal in the American mind.
As time progressed, thrift was no longer a simple economic crisis band-aid. Thrift became “so much more than merely saving money– it means personal efficiency, plans, self-control, foresight, prudence, legitimate self-confidence… It means all that makes for character.” This is what S.W. Straus, a philanthropist and businessman, had to say in his book, The Thrift Propaganda in America. The idea of thrift was elevated to where the American Society for Thrift led by Straus, declared that they spread the gospel of thrift because it provided “practical opportunity of serving our country.” Impactfully, servitude for the United States rings as a sense of duty and vocation; further illuminating the emphasis of thrift and how it has since been raised to such a high pedestal.
In stark contrast, thriftiness today isn’t as highly held in terms of the value that it has in itself as a philosophical ideology, a condition of being, or the economic advantages it may bring. Rather, thriftiness in practice today is centered on the economic-utilitarian view, where money-saving and the personal pleasure in finding nifty knick-knacks underscore its core value.
This does not imply that the individual consumer is not interested in anything other than money and pleasure. Many people who practice thriftiness do so for environmental and ethical reasons like climate change or issues regarding labor exploitation. Regardless of the differing consumer reasons for thrifting, thrift as a value has returned to its roots as it was once known in the culture of 1919.