• About The Pepperdine Beacon
  • Founder’s Statement
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
Sunday, November 15, 2026
The Pepperdine Beacon
  • News
  • Alumni
  • Faith
  • Life And Arts
    • Best of the Best Professors Awards
  • Opinion
    • Faculty
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
The Pepperdine Beacon
  • News
  • Alumni
  • Faith
  • Life And Arts
    • Best of the Best Professors Awards
  • Opinion
    • Faculty
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
The Pepperdine Beacon
No Result
View All Result

Revising the Presidential Pardon Process: Returning Merit to the System

Beyond Tradition: Creating a System of Integrity

Caroline Fleenor by Caroline Fleenor
January 19, 2024
in National, Opinion
Reading Time: 6 mins read
1
Revising the Presidential Pardon Process: Returning Merit to the System
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

The first-ever presidential pardon was issued in 1795 by President George Washington. Since Washington’s pardon of two Americans associated with the Whiskey Rebellion, there have been questions raised about the wisdom of the president’s pardon power. Over 225 years later, this executive power is still in use and has grown even more controversial. Many rightly point out that the current system is rife with corruption. 

The process is cloaked in secrecy and many pardons are given to political loyalists, top government officials, donors who are well-connected to a candidate or political party, and on occasion, citizens who are deserving of a pardon. Additionally, the optics of granting pardons in the last weeks of an administration appear to validate the unseemliness of some of the more egregious pardons. The timing also reduces accountability and consequences for the outgoing administration.

While there have been many proposed reforms to address these concerns, I believe that there are two reforms that would meaningfully improve the pardon process. The first would create a more robust process for granting pardons by creating a requirement that the president issue a public report detailing all correspondence related to the pardon request. The second would establish a Congressional review process. If instituted, these reforms would uphold the Founding Fathers’ intent of this power, improve the transparency of the process, and deter presidents from abusing this privilege.

The power of the presidential pardon is granted in Article II, Section 2, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution. The Constitution provides the president the “Power to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offences against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment.” In simple terms, it allows the chief executive to relieve a person from their punishment which makes them no longer required to follow terms of parole, report on their past convictions for job applications, and pay fines associated with their crime. It also restores their right to vote and own firearms.

When writing the Constitution, the Founding Fathers created the presidential pardon power to be used as a check against the judicial branch of government. Its use in the system of checks and balances significantly limits the ability to curtail its abuse. If its use was limited to the first year of a president’s term, the other branches could be at the mercy of the judiciary during the later three years. 

Likewise, if pardons required congressional approval, the executive could be threatened by a coalition of the legislative and judicial branches. As a result, the only option for improving the pardon authority is to rely on the political process by increasing transparency to voters who can exert various forms of political pressure. These can include threatening the incumbent’s reelection efforts, support for their agenda, and the reelection of members of Congress from the incumbent party.

In addition, this authority was to be used in instances where the criminal justice system issued an unfair sentence to an individual. In those instances, the president was given the power to be able to eliminate their sentence. Pardons were also intended to be granted as an act of mercy and forgiveness. For example, President Jimmy Carter offered pardons to Vietnam War draft offenders, recognizing that the merits of U.S. involvement in Southeast Asia were controversial and divisive. Likewise, President Gerald Ford issued a pardon to former President Nixon over his involvement in Watergate, a scandal that many Americans wanted to move on from. In both cases, the pardons, while controversial, were seen as a way to heal America.

However, not all presidents have used the pardon system as intended by the Founding Fathers. In fact, many have argued that the system has been abused due to the questionable nature of many pardons. Presidents have pardoned friends, family, donors, and executive branch staff. Not only have many pardons been questionable, but they also occurred at the expense of those more deserving of a pardon.

To exemplify how the current system fails to work, one just has to look at the actions of the past few administrations. For example, during the last days of President Trump’s term, lobbyists, White House officials, friends, and even the President’s personal lawyer charged thousands of dollars from clients who were seeking a coveted presidential pardon. It appears that these Trump loyalists were trading on their strong relationship with the president. According to OpenSecrets, Matt Schlapp, who chairs the American Conservative Union, received $750,000 dollars for one month’s work. 

His assignment was to obtain a pardon for Parker Petit, the Georgia finance chair of Trump’s 2016 campaign. Although the pardon wasn’t ultimately granted, the lobbying clearly enriched Schlapp, a strong Trump ally. In addition, President Trump even pardoned his daughter’s father-in-law, Charles Kushner, who was convicted of tax crimes, witness tampering, and illegal campaign contributions. Many have speculated that Charles Kushner was granted this pardon due to his familial relationship with President Trump. The optics surrounding many of President Trump’s pardons were concerning and generated calls for reform from Congress.

However, his administration is not alone in the questionable use of this process. President Bill Clinton pardoned his brother, Roger Clinton, for charges which included cocaine possession and drug trafficking. Similarly, President Barack Obama pardoned Willie McCovey, a famous baseball player and well-known donor to the Democratic Party, for his charges of tax fraud. It appears that a growing precedent in the U.S. is for pardons to be granted to the well-connected, moneyed donors, or family and friends of the president.

A Route Forward: Possible Reforms

The presidential pardon system has strayed away from its original intent–to serve as a check on the judicial branch and to show mercy and forgiveness. To address the perennial problem of the abuse of pardon authority, I suggest creating a more robust disclosure process to enhance transparency. The adoption of a detailed process as an additional requirement under Article II, Section 2, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution would be a long-overdue reform to the presidential pardon authority. This would require the president’s administration to submit all correspondence related to the pardon to the Department of Justice. 

Such a requirement would entail the president publishing a public report that details the recipient of the pardon, the merits of the case, all correspondence related to the request, and disclosure regarding if the individual pardoned was hired or was advised by a person who had a relationship in any form with the president. This limitation would help there be more transparency and accountability for the president and deter them from going on a pardoning spree for their friends, family, administration officials, and donors. This report would be turned into the United States Department of Justice and be submitted for public record so Americans can access it. If Americans are unhappy with whom the president decided to pardon, they are now able to voice their concerns while the president is still subject to electoral consequences.

Another suggested reform would be to establish a requirement that upon issuance of a pardon, the Department of Justice and the opposition party in Congress will enter into a quasi-judicial process in which the Department of Justice will defend the pardon and the opposition party in Congress has the option of advising against the pardon granted. After this process is completed, both parties will produce reports arguing for and against the pardon. Within 30 days of completion of the reports, both houses of Congress will have a non-binding vote on the wisdom of the pardon. The idea behind this is to create an adversarial fact-finding process that would shed light on the events that led to the pardon.

To conclude, the usage of the pardon system has strayed from the original intent of the Founding Fathers. Adding the reforms suggested in this paper will enhance transparency and create a process that would add credibility to the pardons. Without these reforms, it is clear that more corruption, greed, and abuse will occur.

Tags: national newsopinion
Caroline Fleenor

Caroline Fleenor

Caroline Fleenor is a Junior studying Economics and Political Science. She joined the Beacon with the intention of having an outlet to bridge the concepts she acquired in the classroom to real-world scenarios. While at Pepperdine, Caroline studied in Japan and Jordan. She is also a member of the women's cross country and track team. Her hobbies include listening to podcasts, traveling abroad (particularly within the Middle East and Japan), and perfecting her at-home coffee skills.

Comments 1

  1. Claudia B. Sangster says:
    3 years ago

    Very informative! I like the suggestion of a full disclosure report. The other option produces (IMHO) too much process for little real gain. Right now, lawfare is being used against too many people and the Presidential pardon is a way to correct the misuse of such tactics. As an attorney, I am appalled at the way the judicial system is being used to ruin people and the pardon is a good release valve to correct the abuse.

    Thank you for writing such a thoughtful analysis!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get The Beacon in Your Inbox

Trending Articles

  • Fizz: Fact or Fiction? 

    Fizz: Fact or Fiction? 

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Gratitude Is Harder Than It Looks

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Why Isn’t Being Alive Enough?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Standing Firm: How Pepperdine’s Statement of Faith Bucks the Secular Trend

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • In Defense of the Feast

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
© 2026 The Pepperdine Beacon

ABOUT | CONTACT US

The Pepperdine Beacon

Freely you have received; freely give.” -Matthew 10:8                  

                  

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About The Pepperdine Beacon
  • Founder’s Statement
  • Board Structure
  • Alumni
  • Our Team
  • Join Our Team
  • Contact Us

© 2021 The Pepperdine Beacon