• About The Pepperdine Beacon
  • Founder’s Statement
  • Our Team
  • Contact Us
Friday, November 6, 2026
The Pepperdine Beacon
  • News
  • Alumni
  • Faith
  • Life And Arts
    • Best of the Best Professors Awards
  • Opinion
    • Faculty
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
The Pepperdine Beacon
  • News
  • Alumni
  • Faith
  • Life And Arts
    • Best of the Best Professors Awards
  • Opinion
    • Faculty
  • Donate
No Result
View All Result
The Pepperdine Beacon
No Result
View All Result

Reflections on the Weisman Controversy, Part Two: What Now?

Abigail Norman and Braeden Wicker by Abigail Norman and Braeden Wicker
November 7, 2025
in Campus News, Life And Arts
Reading Time: 6 mins read
2
Reflections on the Weisman Controversy, Part Two: What Now?
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Editor’s note: This article makes mention of a statement from the University, which was provided to the Beacon by an anonymous University spokesperson. The full text of the statement can be found in part one of this article.

The Weisman Controversy has caught the attention of the entire campus, students and faculty alike. A month later, the aftermath continues to unfold. But what actually happened that led to the closure? Let’s rewind.

The Hold My Hand in Yours exhibition, curated by Museum Director Andrea Gyorody, featured over 20 internationally recognized artists. Advancement oversees the museum, so on October 1, Vice President of Advancement Lauren Cosentino and Executive Director of Advancement Administration Nicole Singer visited and examined the exhibit. Following this visit, artist Elana Mann’s video installation “Call to Arms 2015-2025” was ordered to be turned off due to its “political content.” The video contained protests and segments criticizing anti-immigration policies under the Trump Administration. 

A second artwork came under fire when Cosentino and Singer noticed that AMBOS Collective’s installation “Con Nuestras Manos Construimos Deidades” featured a patch that read “SAVE THE CHILDREN” and “ABOLISH ICE.” While Mann’s video installation was completely turned off, AMBOS was allowed to continue showcasing their work—under the condition that the anti-ICE patch be removed. They refused and, alongside Mann, withdrew their works, resulting in other artists pulling their art in solidarity on October 8, 2025. 

Student Perspectives

Art. Censorship. Freedom. Protest. The narrative around the Weisman controversy, thus far, has zoomed in on the Administration’s decision to censor and control freedom of speech. 

On October 9, students hosted an “Angry Art Night” to artistically protest what they believed to be censorship by plastering their art onto the Freedom Wall. Drawing comparisons to art banning in Nazi Germany, calling out First Lady Joline Gash, and taping around the Freedom Wall’s free speech statement were all elements of tactful messaging devised through the student-orchestrated protest. 

Closing the exhibit did not silence the conversation. It multiplied it—for the artists, students, and faculty. 

One of the presiding concerns is the legality and ethics of the situation. 

In a statement from the University regarding the exhibit’s closure, this was the justification provided: “Because Pepperdine’s established practice with the Weisman Museum has been to avoid overtly political content consistent with the University’s nonprofit status, the museum removed these two pieces from display.” Let’s break this statement down.

Pepperdine is a private, non-profit organization, which indicates that the university is not required to follow the First Amendment’s free speech rules in the same manner as public universities. Therefore, the justification provided by the University is legitimate on legal grounds. Art is a right, unless it infringes on the rights of the private university’s values. However, this does not prohibit the ethics of the situation from being debated.

Faculty Perspectives

But there seems to be a missing perspective in the current narrative. What does the faculty think?

Dr. Charles Hall, a Sociology Professor at Pepperdine, gives his take: “One could reasonably argue that all art carries some degree of political content. In my view, it’s not appropriate for the University to begin adjudicating what qualifies as ‘overtly political’ art.”

From Dr. Hall’s perspective, the Administration’s reasoning for closing the exhibit, albeit legally acceptable, remains inappropriate. On ethical grounds, the University’s statement suggests that the language of “overtly political” can be interpreted to benefit some political perspectives and disadvantage another.  In other words, the University’s choice in weaponizing, or in the very least, utilizing their private, non-profit status to select which art is deemed “overtly political” is understably concerning. 

Dr. Charles Hall is not the only Pepperdine faculty with opinions on the matter. History professor Dr. Stewart Davenport sees this issue as a clear-cut violation of free speech. “Unless I’m missing something,” he said, “this is the most egregious act of censorship that I’ve seen at Pepperdine in my twenty-three years here.”

When asked about whether or not the University still ought to issue an apology, Dr. Davenport said that, “there should be a public apology from the part of the administration, because it is multi-layered. For me, it doesn’t matter what the motivation was. Is this to protect ourselves from the Trump Administration withdrawing federal funds? What the motivation was is irrelevant to me. Who is apologizing for what? Somewhere within this, someone needs to apologize for this censorship.”

Recently, the Fine Arts division issued a statement in response to the closure of the exhibit. In addition to his role as a professor of history, Dr. Davenport additionally serves on the Seaver Faculty Senate, and was a part of an effort from the Humanities division to support the Fine Arts division’s statement. 

“In the Humanities division, we didn’t take the time to write another statement, we just voted to support the Fine Arts division’s statement as is,” he said. “Of the 36 that voted, 33 voted in favor of supporting the statement.”

The faculty reception can be interpreted as a spectrum: spanning from full support of the Administration’s actions for aligning with conservative Christian beliefs to absolute disapproval of how the situation was handled and firmly believing this was an act of censorship. This array of perspectives displays a fracture across campus that needs to be reconciled, but that requires something we have yet to see from the Pepperdine Administration: transparency.

The lack of communication has the faculty in the dark. What are the implications this decision will have on classroom instruction? Professors need clear guidelines, not ambiguity. 

What Now?

Whether they own the mistake or stand by their decision, the Administration needs to publicly voice their position and thereby signal to faculty what the expectations are, while also encouraging students to exercise the same courage required to be a free thinker. 

I want to end by highlighting two particular clauses in Pepperdine’s Affirmative Statement: 

As a Christian university Pepperdine affirms:

(i) that freedom, whether spiritual, intellectual, or economic, is indivisible, and that (ii) the educational process may not, with impunity, be divorced from the divine process.

What happened at the Weisman Museum reflects something much larger than just art and censorship. It represents the inevitable and ongoing tension between faith and ideology. The administration’s intentions were not to censor art, but to re-align Pepperdine with conservative Christian values. Not everyone associates Christianity with politics in the same way, or associates the two at all. However, religion and politics most certainly share a relationship in the case of the Weisman Museum and show the difficulty of integrating faith into the secular Academy. 

That leaves us with the question of what it means to be Christian, and most importantly, how do we encourage intellectual freedom while remaining faithful to our personal convictions?

While the answers to these questions will differ for each individual, ultimately it is our responsibility to turn to God’s Word in search of the truth.

Tags: campus newscensorshipfeaturedweisman museum
Abigail Norman and Braeden Wicker

Abigail Norman and Braeden Wicker

Comments 2

  1. Rob Shearer says:
    12 months ago

    Excellent closing sentence.

    Reply
  2. Connie James says:
    12 months ago

    The exhibition also impacted our Christian values and campus climate. The exhibit served both academic inquiry and supporting an underrepresented community. We engage in service as an outpouring of our Christian values. They reflect respect for individuals, kindness, compassion, and trying to understand someone else’s unique lived experience. The loss of this exhibit in this manner sorely tested these values, which are neither liberal or conservative.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get The Beacon in Your Inbox

Trending Articles

  • In Defense of the Feast

    In Defense of the Feast

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Small Comforts, Big Questions: Implications of the Squishy Craze

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Mapping the Mind in Motion: How a Tiny Microscope Is Changing Neuroscience

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Are We Taking the Extraordinary for Granted?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Stop Romanticizing Burnout

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
© 2026 The Pepperdine Beacon

ABOUT | CONTACT US

The Pepperdine Beacon

Freely you have received; freely give.” -Matthew 10:8                  

                  

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
  • About The Pepperdine Beacon
  • Founder’s Statement
  • Board Structure
  • Alumni
  • Our Team
  • Join Our Team
  • Contact Us

© 2021 The Pepperdine Beacon