Interview with John Ellis was conducted and written in April 2025.
“If everybody in the same room agrees, there’s no one in the room to point out when one of them says something foolish.”
It is hard to ignore the growing belief that the quality of education at American universities is in decline. As students at Pepperdine, it is important to stay informed on such a crucial issue, as it is our education that is on the line. John Ellis addresses these issues in his book, The Breakdown of Higher Education, by exploring the roots of this academic decline, examining how it began, how far it has spread, and what might be done to fix it. While his analysis raises urgent national concerns, one question remained with me after reading this book: Does the crisis in higher education affect us here at Pepperdine?
On April 5, 2025, I had the privilege of speaking with John Ellis in an exclusive interview for the Beacon.
John Ellis is currently Professor Emeritus of German Literature at the University of California, Santa Cruz, where he has served as dean of the Graduate Division. He has written eleven books throughout his career. Of these works, Literature Lost received the Peter Shaw Memorial Award, and The Breakdown of Higher Education has been widely influential in discussions on academic reform. Ellis was born in London, and after attending London University, he earned a B.A. in German and Philosophy in 1959 and a Ph.D. in German literature in 1965. He has since taught at the University of Wales, Leicester, and Alberta.
In 1993, Ellis founded and served as the treasurer of the Association of Literary Scholars and Critics, a group with the goal of reversing the regression in academic integrity on college campuses in America. He is also the Chairman of the Board of the California Association of Scholars.
I began by asking Dr. Ellis about the start of his career. He explained the impact of growing up in London during the Second World War and how he decided to dedicate his life to teaching at universities. In the midst of his career as a professor and scholar of German Literature, Ellis first began to witness how “the academic war was going downhill.” Ellis explained: “The point of university teaching, being different from high school teaching, is you want students to get involved in that process of original thinking.” He then added grimly: “About 1985, perhaps a bit before, it was becoming clear to me that an awful lot of university professors no longer had that same attitude.”
“I train students in how to get their teeth into problems and think them through, and what these professors now are doing is the reverse of that. They were actually spoon feeding the students their philosophy and wanting them to swallow it, and be followed. They, in other words, were turning out people who thought the way they did, whereas what I wanted to do was turn out kids who could think for themselves and sort out problems in 10-20 years time that I couldn’t even imagine would be there. That would be the point. So, anyways, I started to write about the way in which our education was changing, and in changing was abandoning its real mission. And that’s what my last three or four books are about.”
Of these last four books Dr. Ellis referred to, we focused on his 2020 publication, A Breakdown of Higher Education. When asked about the premise of the book, Ellis began by providing more context:
“The change of mission is the key issue. I mean, once you start to have a professor in front of a class and his aim is to produce people who think like him, let’s say, an ideology, a way of looking at the world, he wants them to adopt that ideology and not question it and run with it. Once you take that as your aim, it seems to me that you’ve betrayed the university mission. . . I’m just trying to open students’ minds up, and these professors are closing them down.”
With this context established, Dr. Ellis summarized his book with this sentence: “I made the opening part of the book an explanation of how it was possible that you could actually have this happen. And then, having done that, I explained a bit more about precisely what it was that has happened–what was wrong with it, and then what could be done about it.”
Regarding the latter part of this statement, Ellis explained the first step to conquering this widespread issue: “The public [must believe] something is really so wrong that it’s got to be changed. I think that is a requirement. We’re getting there on that one. Even so, it still needs to keep going. I mean, we still need to have that perception sink deeper and deeper into the public. But then the question arises: What levels do you have? What steps can you actually take?”
Ellis proceeded to answer his own question by discussing the dangers of political monopolies and polarized faculties. He said, “When you have a political monopoly, it guarantees foolishness, because you don’t have a healthy sort of discipline in place. And if everybody in the same room agrees, there’s no one in the room to point out when one of them says something foolish.”
Ellis concluded by saying: “Get the public, you know, behind the notion that reform is needed. You’ve got to get them to get their legislators to understand that that’s how the public feels.”
In addressing these questions, Dr. Ellis effectively encapsulated the key arguments presented in The Breakdown of Higher Education. However, the question still remains: Where does Pepperdine fit into this situation? I asked Dr. Ellis:
How do you view the role of private institutions like Pepperine in the context of your argument? Do you think that smaller private universities are better positioned to avoid these problems, or do they face the same challenges?
He answered by posing the question: “Do the trustees of Pepperdine, have they been absorbed into the political monopoly? If those trustees include several people who cling to the old mission, the mission of the university, to advance knowledge, to get students up to the point where they themselves are ready to advance knowledge, if the majority of the trustees hold to that, then anything is possible.” He then added: “The alumni may well be a fairly serious factor.” Pepperdine’s Board of Regents is composed of business and civic leaders who actively support the university’s mission through policy maintenance and financial donations. Therefore, it is certainly worthwhile to examine the sources of these funds to gain a clearer understanding of the values and priorities that may influence the school.
We briefly discussed his most recent book, titled A Short History of Relations Between Peoples: How the World Began to Move Beyond Tribalism. Ellis clarified that the book “is a continuation of the going after the ideology of the campuses.”
Now, the most crucial question: How can we, as Pepperdine students, ensure that we are receiving a proper education? Dr. Ellis discussed his granddaughter, who studied English at the University of Southern California. He explained: “She did in fact manage to find a first-class education by just very carefully researching who the professors were. . . The other thing is to just read a lot. . . You read widely and read the books that are central to our tradition. If your professors don’t prescribe Dickens, Shakespeare, or Jane Austen, read them anyway. The great 18th-century philosophers, they have so much to teach you.”
The Beacon aims to foster constructive and transparent discussions among the Pepperdine community, and for that reason, it is crucial that we discuss this matter so that we are not blind to potential holes in our education. By taking the advice of John Ellis, Pepperdine students can make certain that they truly learn. We can begin by keeping open but skeptical minds, engaging deeply with the great books of tradition, and sufficiently educating ourselves about the challenges facing our society. As John Ellis emphasized, the first step toward meaningful change is to become informed. By staying aware, we protect ourselves from a false education, one that manipulates rather than enlightens the mind.